Wheeler’s Corner
“Connecting Citizens Who Care“. Every Monday
at 4 pm on Access Manawatu 999AM” Join Peter’s blog http://wheelerscornernz.blogspot.com/
29th January 2016
This week: 1. Are letters to the Editor a thing of the past?
Does
your local newspaper become more than useless when it selectively decides not to
publish letters to the editor on a topic of currant and topical interest?
I
would suggest when it fails to publish in an attempt to keep the public
uninformed because of politically contrived reasons.
The
1st letter below was sent over eight days [plus] ago, and has not been
published. That could be called an error. But when combined with the second
letter which has not yet been published one could be forgiven for thinking that
the Fairfax owned Manawatu Standard is following a nationwide pattern of
downplaying the opposition to the TPPA, which according to the latest online
polls is supported by around 60 to 80%.
Unpublished
letter one: Is this letter so shocking that it deserves being ignored or censored?
TO: editor@msl.co.nz
Our
government seems hell-bent on giving away our functions as a free and
independent nation in international trading – without consulting the citizenry
– as it proceeds to host the signing of the Trans Pacific Partnership trade
deal (TTPA) early next month. The process also seems to encompass plans to
ensure that NZ voters have no power: thousands of informed citizens - concerned
that 'the deal' will allow foreign corporations to dictate disadvantageous
trading policies to us and put our economy at risk – have lodged protests and
found themselves ignored, essentially disenfranchised!
Do
these circumstances point to some plan designed to obtain enhanced status for
its MPs seeking benefits from foreign interests ( – think Hawaii!) by
nullifying NZ debates? Our former PN mayor (now PN National list MP) has been
quoted by Manawatu Standard reporter Georgia Forrester, January 16, as stating
that debate about the TTPA was “unfounded protest.” “Some of it is just
politically motivated.” Does he see a great political future for himself, now
that he wants to dictate policy from Wellington?
The
TTPA - Free protests will be in evidence everywhere in the next few weeks. One
gets the impression that our National representatives don't give a damn. If
“Politically Motivated” protests are ineffectual, what will we have to do to
get our so-called representatives to take notice?
Name,
address etc. was supplied.
[I’ve
kept the name and address secret so as to ensure that the police don’t visit
the writer as appears to happening elsewhere around the counntry]
Letter
Two:
Editor
MS
According
to Fairfax NZ [Manawatu Standard] report Monday 25th January 2016:
“Prime Minister John Key has defended his
Government's support for the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement in a fiery
speech to Ratana followers.
I
found it hard to accept that stupid statement especially since I can find
nothing that would support the word ‘Fiery’.
Key's speech came after others at the annual
Ratana Church celebrations expressed misgivings about the free trade deal and
urged the Government to delay its signing, set down for February 4 in Auckland,
until it is discussed more thoroughly with Kiwis.
Fears of a sizeable protest from anti-TPPA
protesters at the event did not materialise, but several speeches made
reference to the deal and how it could affect New Zealanders.
Here
yet again the reporter created an illusion by stating:
After fielding criticism, Key responded with an
impassioned address about his support for Maori which drew heckles from
some in the crowd.
The
word ‘impassioned’ simply creates a so-called sincere feeling or emotion by
Key…yet the report does no such thing.
Key said his Government had improved the
condition of Housing New Zealand homes in Ratana, and had improved the living
conditions of both Maori and New Zealand as a whole.
This
as is well understood by those who take an active interest in housing was
simply crap of the highest order. Key went on to push the PR line that:
"This is a country that has the
third-highest employment rate in the OECD; this is a country where wages are
rising [Really], where the crime rate is falling [Really], where health
outcomes are getting better [Says who].
Key defended the secrecy around TPPA
negotiations, saying "every single free trade agreement negotiated by any
government, with Labour or National", had been negotiated in confidence.
This
of course is the big lie…in fact if you tell this massive fib enough times some
people might actually believe it to be true…The PM then had the audacity to
state:
Maori needed to "stand up for your
young people" by supporting the deal and the economic benefits it would
bring to New Zealand.
"Stand
up for your young people; because your young people deserve a
chance to get a job, your economy deserves a chance to succeed.
The TPPA text was "absolutely crystal
clear" about the economic benefits for Kiwis and the clauses that were in
place to protect New Zealand, Key said.
The
only problem was nothing in the news item related to the text that describes
the benefits that Key considers so obvious. So we could ask what benefits are
obvious. Perhaps Jono Naylor could tell us about the benefits on Friday the 29th
January 2016 at 11am when people are assembling at his electorate office at 45
King St.
Peter
Wheeler
29d
West Street PN
359-2030
[I’m
happy to reveal my contact details so that the police can visit me at any time
to discuss my action plans regarding the TPPA, as I understand it NZ has no
laws that ban protests etc.
Peter
J Wheeler
1 comment:
This from the Editor MS newspaper
Peter,
For someone who so vehemently demands the truth from politicians and the media, you appear to have no problem in twisting it for your own purposes.
I think if you'd actually taken the time to do a true and fair analysis of the Manawatu Standard's coverage of the TPPA, you would see that we have presented a balanced view of the issue from the beginning. Our coverage has included multiple stories that have featured comment from both sides of the issue.
In fact we have rarely missed a public meeting, discussion or debate on the TPPA - the protest at Jono Naylor's office today being no exception.
The reason your letter has not been printed in the Standard yet is because we don't run letters in every edition, preferring instead to bank them up and run them when the best opportunity arises. I will also note that, at 460 words in length, your letter is more than double the preferred 200 word length. Exceptions can, of course, be made.
We have run a number of your letters in the past, many of which have not always been complimentary of our coverage. I can assure you that your salvos against content produced by the Standard or the Fairfax stable are not determining factors in whether or not we would run such a letter.
Of course you might have been able to clear this up with a phone call or a follow up email to me, but instead you chose to perpetuate a conspiracy theory that has absolutely zero grounding in reality.
All the best,
Jonathon Howe
Manawatu editor
Post a Comment